Skip to content

Search

Latest Stories

Submit Guest Post

The hotel owner’s dilemma: Renovate, reposition or hold

When and how to invest capital in an asset or let it go

The hotel owner’s dilemma: Renovate, reposition or hold

The decision to invest capital in a particular property involves many factors depending on what can be done to derive more value from the asset, according to Sandeep Wadhwa, chairman of FAY Investment Group.

Photo credit: iStock

Hotel owners constantly decide where the next dollar of capital should go. Rooms age, competitors improve their product and guest expectations change. New opportunities also emerge around wellness, food and beverage, recreation, events and elevated programming.

Investment is easy to justify. Creating value from that investment is harder. A hotel with strong demand and a dated physical product may need a focused renovation. A property with good infrastructure but an outdated market position may require repositioning. A well-performing asset may create greater value by preserving capital and continuing to operate.


These are different investment decisions. Each requires a clear understanding of the asset, its customers, its economics and the cost of capital.

Start with the asset

The first step is to identify what is actually holding the property back.

Some hotels have strong locations, established demand and sound operating models but need physical improvements. Others have substantial infrastructure but have lost relevance with their target customer.

Renovation works when the underlying proposition remains strong. Upgrading rooms, restaurants, pools, public areas and recreational facilities can improve guest satisfaction, support pricing and strengthen operating performance.

The investment becomes more compelling when each improvement has a commercial purpose. A restaurant should increase utilisation and spending. A pool can support food and beverage, premium access and longer stays. A wellness facility can attract incremental demand and generate additional revenue. The physical improvement needs to translate into better economics.

Repositioning changes how the asset earns

Repositioning addresses a larger problem. The property needs to compete differently.

A resort may have restaurants, meeting spaces, outdoor areas, recreational facilities and land that are not being fully monetised. The opportunity may not require building more. It may require changing the customer proposition and making better use of what already exists.

This is where experience-led hospitality becomes important.

Wellness, elevated programming, food and beverage, recreation, entertainment and events can create new reasons to visit and new sources of revenue. Wellness retreats can attract new customers. Seasonal programming can strengthen demand during softer periods. Culinary experiences can increase on-property spending. Events can expand the customer base beyond overnight guests.

The broader opportunity is significant. The Global Wellness Institute estimates that global wellness tourism expenditure reached approximately $894 billion in 2024.

For hotel owners, the lesson is not to add amenities simply because they are fashionable. The experience needs to fit the destination, the customer and the economics of the property.

A room remains the foundation of the hotel business. The experiences around that room increasingly determine how much value the property captures from each guest.

Use the existing asset more effectively

Existing resorts have an advantage that new developments do not. They already have customers, operating data, infrastructure and market relationships.

Owners can use those advantages to test new concepts before committing substantial capital.

A wellness programme can establish demand before a larger facility is developed. Elevated programming can demonstrate the potential of seasonal experiences. An underused restaurant can be repositioned before a major expansion. Meeting space can support corporate retreats, weddings and events without requiring a new building.

This creates a more disciplined capital cycle. Demand can be tested, performance measured and capital directed towards the areas producing the strongest returns.

The capital stack matters

The operating strategy cannot be separated from the financing strategy.

Senior debt, equity, preferred equity and mezzanine financing each carry different costs and risk. The right structure gives an owner flexibility while protecting the operating business from excessive financial pressure.

EB-5 can form part of the capital stack for qualifying U.S. hospitality projects, subject to applicable programme requirements and the specific project structure.

For redevelopment and repositioning, EB-5 can provide another source of project capital alongside conventional debt and equity. Its role should be evaluated within the complete capital structure and the economics of the project.

The financing structure also influences the pace of investment. Acquisition, renovation, repositioning and stabilisation can require different amounts and forms of capital.

A strong operating plan therefore needs a capital structure that supports the strategy rather than constrains it.

Holding can be the right investment decision

Not every hotel needs a renovation. Not every resort needs a repositioning.

Some properties already generate attractive cash flow, and the incremental return from additional capital may not justify the investment. Higher financing costs can further weaken the case.

Temporary weakness also needs to be distinguished from structural underperformance. A period of lower occupancy does not automatically mean the property requires a major capital programme.

Holding allows an owner to preserve capital, maintain cash flow and wait for a stronger investment opportunity.

Patience becomes particularly valuable when the expected return from spending is lower than the return available from protecting existing cash flow or deploying capital elsewhere.

Avoid the renovation trap

The renovation trap begins when physical improvement becomes the investment thesis.

A new lobby can improve the arrival experience. New rooms can improve guest satisfaction. A redesigned restaurant can modernise the property.

The investment case still needs to demonstrate an economic return. Owners should examine ADR, occupancy, RevPAR, total revenue, ancillary spending, operating margins and NOI. Capital cost per key, payback period and stabilised asset value should also form part of the analysis.

A large renovation that produces only modest incremental earnings may create a better-looking hotel without creating a better investment.

A repositioning programme that expands the customer base, increases utilisation and introduces new revenue streams can produce a much stronger outcome.

Timing changes the equation

Construction costs, interest rates, competitive supply and consumer behaviour all influence the decision.

So does the opportunity cost of capital. Capital committed to one property cannot be deployed elsewhere. A lengthy renovation can also disrupt operations and reduce revenue while work is underway.

Existing hotels provide an important advantage because they already have an operating business. Owners can phase investment, protect cash flow and respond to actual customer behaviour.

That flexibility should be reflected in the investment strategy.

Make the decision at the asset level

Renovate when the business works and the physical product needs to catch up.

Reposition when the property has valuable infrastructure and market potential but its customer proposition or revenue model needs to change.

Hold when the asset generates attractive returns and additional capital offers limited incremental value.

Sell when the future capital requirement exceeds the value the asset can reasonably create or when another owner can extract greater value.

The same portfolio can require all four strategies.

The strongest hotel owners do not measure success by how much capital they deploy. They measure it by what that capital changes.

A renovation should improve the economics of an existing proposition. A repositioning should create a stronger business. Wellness and elevated programming should generate genuine demand and revenue. The capital stack should support the strategy at an appropriate cost.

And when the numbers do not support further investment, holding the asset can be the most disciplined decision of all.

Hotel ownership ultimately comes down to capital allocation. The best owners know when to improve the product, when to change the proposition and when to leave a good asset alone.

Add Asian Hospitality As Your Trusted Source
preferred source on google news

More for you