Skip to content

Search

Latest Stories

STR moves to dismiss antitrust lawsuit

The research firm says the plaintiffs failed to show a knowing conspiracy by participants in its “Forward STAR” program

STR moves to dismiss antitrust lawsuit

STR FILED A motion to dismiss a lawsuit that claims it, along with several major hotel companies conspired to inflate luxury hotel rates. The research firm said in the motion that the seven individuals named as plaintiffs in the lawsuit failed to show a knowing conspiracy to fix prices through STR’s “Forward STAR” program in violation of federal antitrust laws.

The lawsuit, filed in February in federal court in Washington state, alleges that STR, owned by commercial real estate information researcher CoStar Group, and hotel companies including IHG Hotel & Resorts, Marriott International and Hyatt Hotels Corp., entered an exchange of “competitively-sensitive information about their prices, supply, and future plans” in violation of the antitrust provisions of the Sherman Act, according to the lawsuit.


The plaintiffs seek to make it a class-action filing on behalf of every person who stayed at the defendants’ hotels from February 2020 until the present for an unspecified amount. However, STR’s motion claims it fails to provide evidence of any illegal actions and is mistakenly part of a current legal trend.

“This case is about hotel industry benchmarking reports that STR has been producing for over 35 years. Plaintiffs’ allegations, which in some ways attempt to mimic other recent lawsuits aimed at various forms of ‘algorithmic pricing,’ are misdirected at STR reports, which involve neither algorithms nor pricing recommendations,” STR’s motion says. “Instead, STR’s reports only provide customers with benchmarks against occupancy and historical revenue data aggregated and averaged from typically at least five, and often many more, other hotels.”

Four points

The motion calls the lawsuit’s allegations a “fanciful claim” that fails to meet four specific standards to be considered.

  • It fails to answer “basic questions” regarding the alleged conspiracy, as required by the Ninth Circuit to plead a Sherman Act Section 1 claim.
  • It does not allege any direct or circumstantial evidence of an agreement among the hotel defendants to exchange competitively sensitive information through STR.
  • It does not plead any anticompetitive effects from the alleged conspiracy.
  • It does not make a sufficient causal connection between plaintiffs’ alleged injury, increased prices for luxury hotel rooms, and the alleged conspiracy.

“STR stands by its long-standing practice of providing the hotel industry with competition-enhancing analysis,” the firm said in a statement. “Since its founding in 1985, STR has been committed to providing the industry with the highest-quality insights, while simultaneously protecting the confidentiality of client data through aggregation and anonymization. STR will therefore vigorously defend itself in the lawsuit.”

Allegations of an alliance to fix prices

Steve Berman, the plaintiffs' lead attorney, did not respond to a request for comment on STR’s motion to dismiss in time for this article.

“Teddy Roosevelt passed the antitrust laws to prevent titans of industry from price fixing in smoke-filled rooms,” Berman previously told Reuters, calling the defendants' conduct the "modern equivalent."

The alleged price fixing happened in major cities including Boston, Chicago, Los Angeles, New York, San Diego, Denver, Washington, D.C., and Seattle. The lawsuit focuses on STR’s “Forward STAR” product that was expanded into many of those markets in April after launching 17 of the country’s 25 largest hotel markets, including Las Vegas, New York City, Los Angeles, Washington, D.C., Boston and Phoenix.

Forward STAR allows hotel property and portfolio users to benchmark the next 365 days of occupancy on the books against the competition and market.

“The purpose of this exchange is for competitors to share ‘super-timely revenue and occupancy data’ so that competitors can ensure they are each getting their ‘fair share’ of revenues,” the lawsuit says. “In other words, the exchange of this information allows participating hotels to set prices higher than they would have been absent this agreement to exchange information. This is price fixing in its modern form and is illegal under the Sherman Act.”

STR requires the information exchange in its contract with participating companies, the lawsuit said.

“A hotel operator has to give information to STR in order to receive benchmarking information back,” the lawsuit said. “The license agreement states that ‘CoStar is under no obligation to provide to any hotel benchmarking deliverables if licensee does not provide the applicable hotel data to CoStar based on such data guidelines and timeframes,’ and its service ‘is subject to and contingent on licensee providing CoStar timely, true, accurate, correct and complete hotel data as required.’”

One of the confidential witnesses cited in the lawsuit is a former software engineer at STR.

“[The witness] stated that ‘almost everybody’ within the hotel industry in the U.S. was an STR client and received STR reports,” the lawsuit said. “Marriott, Hilton and Holiday Inn were all STR clients, just to name a few, she said. CW 2 recalled that STR ‘had very few competitors’ and ‘we were kind of servicing everyone. There wasn’t anyone else that did it.’”

More for you

Trump H1B visa fee India
Photo by Andrew Harnik/Getty Images

Trump’s $100K H-1B fee sparks panic in India

Summary:

  • Announcement of $100,000 H-1B visa fee triggers panic among Indian professionals.
  • The fee applies only to new petitions.
  • IT companies are reportedly reviewing staffing and travel.

THE TRUMP ADMINISTRATION’S announcement of a $100,000 fee for new H-1B visa petitions, effective Sept. 21, reportedly triggered panic among Indian H-1B holders. Many rushed to book last-minute flights, resulting in fully booked planes and higher fares.

Keep ReadingShow less
H-2B visa hospitality impact

Study: H-2B visas boost U.S. jobs and wages

Summary:

  • The H-2B visa program protects U.S. jobs and wages, according to AHLA citing a study.
  • It allows hotels and resorts to meet travelers’ needs while supporting the economy.
  • It provides foreign workers for seasonal jobs when domestic workers are unavailable.

THE H-2B VISA program does not harm U.S. jobs or wages but increases pay and supports the labor force, according to an Edgeworth Economics study. Citing that study, the American Hotel & Lodging Association said the program enables hotels and resorts to meet travelers’ needs while supporting the workforce and economy.

Keep ReadingShow less
AI digital assistant redefining guest loyalty in U.S. hospitality industry

Study: AI agents redefine hotel loyalty

Summary:

  • The use of AI agents hotels must rethink customer loyalty, a FAU study finds.
  • The paper proposes strategies as AI becomes the main booking channel.
  • Researchers warn of ethical and privacy issues.

HOTELS MUST RETHINK how they build and maintain loyalty as artificial intelligence systems make travel decisions and bookings for consumers, according to a study by Florida Atlantic University. The rise of artificial intelligence agents will complicate hotel customer loyalty management.

Keep ReadingShow less
HAMA Fall 2025 survey results

Survey: Hotels expect Q4 RevPAR gain

Summary:

  • More than 70 percent expect a RevPAR increase in Q4, according to HAMA survey.
  • Demand is the top concern, cited by 77.8 percent, up from 65 percent in spring.
  • Only 37 percent expect a U.S. recession in 2025, down from 49 percent earlier in the year.

MORE THAN 70 PERCENT of respondents to a Hospitality Asset Managers Association survey expect a 1 to 3 percent RevPAR increase in the fourth quarter. Demand is the top concern, cited by 77.8 percent of respondents, up from 65 percent in the spring survey.

Keep ReadingShow less
Peachtree Group DST Mansfield Texas

Peachtree adds Mansfield, TX, industrial asset to DST

Summary:

  • Peachtree launched new DST with 131,040‑square foot industrial facility in Mansfield, Texas.
  • The property was acquired at $180 per square foot.
  • Peachtree completed $320M in debt-free transactions across multiple markets since 2022.

PEACHTREE GROUP LAUNCHED its latest Delaware Statutory Trust with the acquisition of a newly built 131,040-square-foot industrial facility in Mansfield, Texas. The company has completed about $320 million in debt-free transactions since launching its DST program in 2022, according to its statement.

Keep ReadingShow less