Skip to content

Search

Latest Stories

Choice, Wyndham debate proposed merger during 2023 earnings calls

Four state attorneys general are reportedly investigating the proposed acquisition, already under review by the FTC

Choice, Wyndham debate proposed merger during 2023 earnings calls

THE FOURTH QUARTER/ full-year 2023 earnings calls for Choice Hotels International and Wyndham Hotels & Resorts became opportunities for both companies to exchange barbs over Choice’s proposed acquisition of Wyndham. Also, four state attorneys general are reportedly examining the proposed acquisition, possibly to begin their own investigations.

Wyndham’s board of directors has consistently declined Choice’s proposal, saying it faces regulatory challenges and undervalues Wyndham’s standalone worth. On Feb. 14, in Wyndham’s earnings call, Geoff Ballotti, the company’s president and CEO, mentioned the Choice proposal in his summation of the results that included record rooms growth.


“We are tremendously proud to report fourth quarter results that demonstrate the continued success of our global strategy and our accelerating momentum,” Ballotti said.  “Despite the distraction, uncertainty and misperceptions caused by Choice and their slanted and constant communications to our franchisee base, room openings accelerated and our global development pipeline grew by 10 percent to an all-time high of 240,000 rooms.”

Choice vows to push for the deal

Choice also reported that strong results from 2023 in its earnings call on Feb. 20. The company’s total revenues grew 10 percent to $1.5 billion for 2023 compared to 2022, a record. Its net income was $258.5 million for 2023, a diluted EPS of $5.07. EBITDA for 2023 reached a company record of $540.5 million, 13 percent more than 2022 and higher than the top end of the company's guidance for last year.

Choice’s global pipeline as of Dec. 31 increased 6 percent to more than 105,000 rooms from Sept. 30. The global pipeline for conversion rooms increased by 16 percent from Sept. 30 and 34 percent from Dec. 31, 2022. Pat Pacious, Choice’s president and CEO, then said the results underscored the company’s readiness for the deal with Wyndham.

"Our demonstrated track record of improving the delivery of direct business to franchisees positions us to further accelerate value creation for all stakeholders through a compelling combination with Wyndham,” Pacious said. “We are confident we can create meaningful value for franchisees and shareholders of both companies. We are committed to pursuing this combination and remain encouraged by our progress on the regulatory front.”

Pacious also mentioned Choice’s nomination of eight nominees for Wyndham’s board of directors who will be voted on during Wyndham’s 2024 shareholders meeting.

“If elected, these nominees will exercise their independent judgment to serve Wyndham shareholders' best interests, which we continue to believe is to move with urgency to maximize the value that can be created through a combination with Choice," he said.

Later, Stephen Holmes, chairman of Wyndham’s board, responded to claims he said Pacious made during the earnings call that implied that Wyndham had “refused to engage” with Choice about the deal.

“Nothing is further from the truth. We have engaged. What we have not done is roll over,” Holmes said. “The truth is this: our Board connected with Choice and its advisors over 25 times since April 2023 including on some occasions at our initiative. We consistently, explicitly, and repeatedly explained the core issues Choice would need to address to make its proposed offer attractive, reasonably certain, and feasible for Wyndham and its shareholders. Despite our extensive and genuine engagement, Choice has addressed none of these issues. It has, instead, adopted this completely misleading tactic to divert attention away from its own unwillingness to address the realities.”

In its original proposal, made public in October, Choice said it sought to acquire all the outstanding shares of Wyndham at a price of $90 per share and shareholders would have received $49.50 in cash and 0.324 shares of Choice common stock for each Wyndham share they own. Choice claimed that is a 30 percent premium to Wyndham’s 30-day volume-weighted average closing price ending on Oct. 16, an 11 percent premium to Wyndham’s 52-week high, and a 30 percent premium to Wyndham’s latest closing price.

Wyndham’s board unanimously rejected Choice’s proposal, calling it unsolicited, “highly conditional” and not in the best interest of shareholders. On Nov. 14, however, Choice sent a letter to the Wyndham board with an “enhanced proposal” intended to address Wyndham’s concerns about clearing federal regulations. On Dec. 12, Choice launched  its public exchange offer to acquire Wyndham and on Dec. 19 the Wyndham board officially rejected the offer and urged shareholders not to tender shares for the deal.

State AGs getting involved

According to Wyndham, state attorneys general in Colorado, Washington, Kansas and Vermont have begun their own investigations into the proposed acquisition. The Federal Trade Commission is already in the process of reviewing the deal.

“Each of [the attorneys general] have opened their own separate investigations with the power to investigate the transaction on their own timelines and with the power to seek to block the transaction in court independent of any decision by the FTC,” Wyndham said on its website about the acquisition.

State Antitrust Enforcement Act of 2022 limits ability of states to consolidate cases such as this, and usually states cooperate with the FTC and Department of Justice in antitrust investigations. Both companies have to give permission for the information they have submitted to the FTC regarding the acquisition to be shared with the AGs.

Requests for confirmation from three of the four AGs offices were not returned in time for this article. A spokesperson for the Washington State Attorney General’s Office said it was their policy not to comment on ongoing investigations, “including confirming whether or not they exist.”

There is precedent. On Feb. 14, Colorado Attorney General Phil Weiser announced he is suing to block a merger between the Kroger Co. and Albertsons Co. grocery store chains. Kroger announced in October its intention to purchase Albertsons for $24.6 billion. Kroger operates 148 stores in Colorado under the King Soopers and City Market banners and Albertsons operates 105 stores in the state under the Safeway and Albertsons banners. The companies expect to finalize the merger in early 2024 if it is approved by state and federal regulators.

According to Weiser’s office, the merger would “eliminate head-to-head competition between Kroger and Albertsons and consolidate an already heavily concentrated market, which is bad for Colorado shoppers, workers, and suppliers.”

“Coloradans are concerned about undue consolidation and its harmful impacts on consumers, workers, and suppliers,” Weiser said. “After 19 town halls across the state, I am convinced that Coloradans think this merger between the two supermarket chains would lead to stores closing, higher prices, fewer jobs, worse customer service, and less resilient supply chains.”

More for you

Trump reviewing 55 million us visas
Getty Images

Trump reviewing 55 million visas

Summary:

  • The Trump administration says it is reviewing more than 55 million visa holders.
  • Reviews cover a wide range of visas for law enforcement and overstay violations.
  • The administration also suspended worker visas for foreign commercial truck drivers.

THE TRUMP ADMINISTRATION is reviewing more than 55 million people who hold valid U.S. visas for potential violations. It is expanding a policy of “continuous vetting” that could result in revocation and deportation.

Keep ReadingShow less
Peachtree Funds Rio Las Vegas Renovations | $176M CPACE Loan
Photo credit: Hyatt Hotels Corp.

Peachtree originates retroactive CPACE loan for Rio Vegas

Summary:

  • Peachtree Group originated a $176.5 million retroactive CPACE loan for a Las Vegas property.
  • The deal closed in under 60 days and ranks among the largest CPACE financings in the U.S.
  • The company promotes retroactive CPACE funding for commercial real estate development.

PEACHTREE GROUP ORIGINATED a $176.5 million retroactive Commercial Property Assessed Clean Energy loan for Dreamscape Cos.’s Rio Hotel & Casino in Las Vegas. The deal, completed in under 60 days, is its largest credit transaction and one of the largest CPACE financings in the U.S.

Keep ReadingShow less
Spark Acquires Home2 Suites Wayne, New Jersey
Photo Credit: Hunter Hotels

Spark acquires Wayne, N.J., Home2 Suites

Summary:

  • Spark acquired the 120-key Home2 Suites by Hilton Wayne in Wayne, New Jersey.
  • Hunter Hotel Advisors facilitated the transaction with DC Hospitality Group affiliates.
  • The 2020-built hotel is near William Paterson University and less than 20 miles from Manhattan.

SPARK GHC RECENTLY acquired the 120-key Home2 Suites by Hilton Wayne in Wayne, New Jersey, from affiliates of DC Hospitality Group. Hunter Hotel Advisors facilitated the deal for an undisclosed amount.

Keep ReadingShow less
Global hotel construction pipeline reaches record 15,871 projects in Q2 2025, with U.S. and Dallas leading growth
Photo Credit: iStock

Report: Global pipeline hits 15,871 projects

Summary:

  • Global pipeline hit a record 15,871 projects with 2.4 million rooms in Q2.
  • The U.S. leads with 6,280 projects; Dallas tops cities with 199.
  • Nearly 2,900 hotels are expected to open worldwide by the end of 2025.

THE GLOBAL HOTEL pipeline reached 15,871 projects, up 3 percent year-over-year, and 2,436,225 rooms, up 2 percent, according to Lodging Econometrics. Most were upper midscale and upscale, LE reported.

Keep ReadingShow less
HAMA Launches 20th Student Case Competition in USA
Photo Credit: iStock

HAMA launches 20th student case competition

Summary:

  • HAMA is accepting submissions for its 20th annual student case competition.
  • The cases reflect a scenario HAMA members faced as owner representatives.
  • Teams must submit a financial analysis, solution and executive summary.

THE HOSPITALITY ASSET Managers Association is accepting submissions for the 20th Annual HAMA Student Case Competition, in which more than 60 students analyze a management company change scenario and provide recommendations. HAMA, HotStats and Lodging Analytics Research & Consulting are providing the case, based on a scenario HAMA members faced as owner representatives.

Keep ReadingShow less